Home
Home News Join Respect Online Donate to Respect Articles Local Pages Policies Multimedia Campaign material Get Involved Events Contact Us Links
Join our mailing list
Subscribe to our RSS feed
All materials published and promoted by L Smith, PO Box 1109, London N4 2UU
Galloway challenges editor over Nazi propaganda
George Galloway this morning wrote to the "Ham and High" newspaper editor following an extraordinary response from the latter to Respect's call on the Archant Group not to carry further BNP adverts.

George will be going through Camden and on to Swiss Cottage and Finchley Road with the Respect Battle Bus this afternoon. He intends to take a slight detour at around 1.30pm to take his anti Nazi message to the offices of the Ham and High in The Avenue, Swiss Cottage.

Here is the full text of the correspondence between George Galloway and Archant.

Letter to Ham and High Editor, 15th April 2008

Dear Mr Martin,

I have yet to receive the courtesy of a reply from the Archant chief executive John Fry, so I am taking this somewhat illiterate and incoherent response from you to the Respect press office to represent what passes for the current thinking of the powers that be on this issue. I therefore also assume the Archant Group will be carrying further adverts from the Nazi British National Party.

The analogy you draw with the broadcast media is entirely spurious. The broadcast media are not permitted by the Advertising Standards Authority to take paid adverts promoting political parties. I have little doubt this is a good thing given the dominance of those with the most money in US elections where there is no such restriction.

Instead promotion of parties is restricted to Party Election Broadcasts provided free to parties which meet certain criteria. Those criteria reflect the levels of support for those parties as indicated either by previous performance or current opinion poll standing and also by the number of candidates the party is standing.

In the case of the London elections a minimum qualification for a PEB is that the party should be standing for the mayoralty, the top up list and in every constituency in the London Assembly. The Nazi BNP has never qualified for a London PEB as it has not stood for the constituency section in the past and is only standing in one constituency this time round. I repeat the Nazi BNP will not be qualifying for a PEB in the London elections 2008.

The Archant Group is a privately owned company with no legal or moral obligation to carry adverts from any organisation promoting any cause or product. The Newspaper Society has made this absolutely clear.

You yourself have written an editorial showing you are well aware of the abhorrent nature of the BNP, so you cannot seek an excuse in your own ignorance. There is no question either of organisations being "excluded" by one media organisation or another in the run-up to elections, although I disagree with your implicit take on this issue.

The fact is the BNP receives election coverage in the reporting of the newspaper media where editors deem this to be appropriate.

Newspaper editors can influence the question of "balance" and freedom of expression where this is felt to be a moral obligation on a paper.

I have to say that your concept of "balance" and freedom of expression seems in fairly short supply amongst the so-called Fleet Street editors, especially of the red tops and I would question whether it is observed even amongst many local papers. However this concept of "balance" cannot possibly apply to advertising.

Advertising is, by definition, not subject to "balance" as it is entirely dependent on who has the resources or the desire to pay you to carry adverts. Does the Archant Group really want to become known as the paid purveyors of Nazi propaganda.

Moreover, local papers operate a policy of covering issues which have a "local" angle. On this criterion, it would be strange indeed if the Ham and High were to give the BNP coverage as you have no local BNP candidates standing and I would have thought you could count the number of BNP voters on one hand in the area you cover, at least until you decided to carry adverts on their behalf.

You say that commercial considerations have not played any role in this extraordinary decision of the Archant Group to carry Nazi adverts. If this is the case, I would have thought Archant's shareholders will have something to say about it because the one thing that is certain is that the decision to carry these adverts is likely to be commercially disastrous for the group.

It will be particularly disastrous for those titles where there is considerable racial harmony, a very low or non-existent BNP presence and where the titles have overcome their previous reputation, earned or unearned, of pandering to the racial prejudices of some of their readers.

I think particularly of the East London Advertiser, my local paper, in this regard which has positioned itself as the paper of record in Tower Hamlets against its previous unsavoury reputation.

The fact is that people of goodwill wholly opposed to the BNP's message of racial hatred will now be strongly inclined to boycott co-operation with or purchase of the papers in the Archant Group and will call on others also to boycott your titles. Perhaps even more importantly for the Archant Group shareholders is the fact that many who might have advertised in the papers in the group will not now do so. I certainly intend to raise with your principal advertisers the desirability of advertising alongside Nazi propaganda.

It is not too late for the Archant Group to acknowledge its intellectual error over issues of free speech in relation to the BNP and for it to make the sensible commercial decision to abandon these adverts and return to the BNP the money it has raised out of its message of race hatred. I trust Mr Fry and his fellow board members will now see through your absurd arguments and analogies and do the right thing.

Yours sincerely,

George Galloway MP
 

News and articles of interest

Here are some articles and news reports we think are worth looking at

From Triumph to Torture by John Pilger
Two weeks ago, I presented a young Palestinian, Mohammed Omer, with the 2008 Martha Gellhorn Prize for Journalism. Awarded in memory of the great US war correspondent, the prize goes to journalists who expose establishment propaganda, or "official drivel", as Gellhorn called it.

SATs school tests criticised by official report by Harvey Thompson and Linda Slattery
In May, millions of school children throughout England undertook their Standard Assessment Tasks (SATs) in English, mathematics and science. The statutory tests are widely considered to be flawed and almost universally reviled by teachers and children alike.

Health: Who asked for choice? - Morning Star
IF Health Minister Ben Bradshaw believes that there is political capital to be made by taking on our NHS doctors, he will quickly come unstuck.

Afghanistan troop deaths outnumber those in Iraq by Angela Balakrishnan and agencies
Militants in Afghanistan killed more US and Nato troops than those in Iraq in June after a fresh spate of rebel attacks that highlighted the growing strength of the Taliban.

Iran legally entitled to develop nuclear energy, says UK MP
Iran is legally entitled to develop nuclear energy under the Non-Proliferation Treaty, according to a British MP visiting Tehran for the first time. George Galloway, who was expelled from Britain's ruling Labor Party for his outspoken opposition to the Iraq war, also criticized the hypocrisy of Israel's belligerence towards Iran, which has its own illegal stockpile of nuclear weapons.

In the Cause of Fear and Ignorance by John Pilger
Muslims are alone as they watch the British state, with its "obstinate incomprehension" of their faith, do to them as it would never do to those of other faiths. Imagine Jews treated this way. You cannot imagine it; the profanity is too great. The silence of British Jews, who have the history, is also great.

Migrant Myths by Adam Ford
As part of her degree course, Kurdish migrant Filiz Celik researched the conditions that workers from overseas face in the United Kingdom. The full text of her study can be read here, but this summary by Adam Ford gives some idea of the reality behind the media-generated myths.

Tesco shareholders reject TV chef's chicken welfare call
Tesco shareholders today voted against a resolution from TV cook Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall which called for the retail giant to improve its chicken-rearing standards.

Academies expelled 10,000 pupils
Academies have been accused of excluding disproportionately high numbers of students after it emerged that they excluded nearly 10,000 pupils for poor behaviour last year.

Let companies run state schools for profit, says Sir Simon Milton
Private companies should be allowed to run state schools at a profit and be free to dismiss teachers who are not up to the job, the head of the Local Government Association (LGA) said yesterday.

For more stories, click here